MyStart Health vs PeterMD: Which GLP-1 Program Is Better? (2026)
We put MyStart Health and PeterMD head-to-head — what you actually pay each month, which GLP-1 medications you can get, the level of clinician support, and where each one wins — so you can pick the cheaper, better-fit weight loss program in minutes.
Quick Verdict
We recommend MyStart Health
Between these two providers, MyStart Health is our pick for most users. It offers a higher overall rating (8.5 vs 5.5), availability in all 50 states, both brand-name and compounded medication options. That said, PeterMD may be the better fit if you are looking for penny-pinchers hunting for the cheapest possible monthly glp-1 price.
MyStart Health scores 8.5/10 in our independent evaluation at $224/month, while PeterMD scores 5.5/10 at $105/month. Both programs connect you with a licensed physician and deliver medication straight to your door. Each score weighs five things: safety and medical oversight (30%), pricing transparency (25%), value for money (20%), quality of clinical support (15%), and how fast you can get started (10%). We build these comparisons ourselves — no provider buys a better rating or a higher spot. Pricing checked April 2026.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | MyStart Health | PeterMD |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Price | $224 | $105 |
| Rating | 8.5 / 10 | 5.5 / 10 |
| Medication Type | Brand & Compounded | Compounded Only |
| Insurance Accepted | No | No |
| States Available | All 50 states | 46 states |
| Consultation Fee | Free | Free |
| Shipping | Free Shipping | Free Shipping |
| Cancel Anytime | Yes | Yes |
| Medical Support | U.S.-licensed doctors you can reach without any cap on clinician visits | Licensed doctors who handle screening over a virtual visit |
Figures show entry-level cash prices before any insurance. What you ultimately pay can change with your plan and the specific medication. Last checked April 2026.
MyStart Health: Detailed Look
MyStart Health
GLP-1 plans backed by a locked-in price and a results-or-refund pledge
Pros
- A locked rate means stepping up your dose never bumps the price
- Drop 10% of your body weight inside four months or get your money back
- One bundled price folds in free shipping and lab work
- Reaches all 50 states and turns consultations around within a day
Cons
- A handful of customers mention delays getting orders shipped out
- Switching to tirzepatide costs a lot more at $429 a month
People who value a money-back results pledge alongside a frozen price
PeterMD: Detailed Look
PeterMD
One of the cheapest GLP-1 programs around, with prices opening at $105/month
Pros
- At roughly $105/month, the entry price is among the lowest out there
- Visits, shipping, and supplies all come at no extra charge
- Close to 14,000 Trustpilot reviews land at an average of 4.8 stars
- Virtual screening and med delivery both move quickly
Cons
- Service after you've paid is hit or miss, with some billing gripes
- Bloodwork isn't offered in AL, ID, NY, or NJ
Penny-pinchers hunting for the cheapest possible monthly GLP-1 price
How to Decide Between Them
There is no single winner for everyone — it comes down to what matters most to you. Match your priority to the scenarios below to see which provider fits:
Go with PeterMD at $105/month. Subscription pairs semaglutide with B12; tirzepatide is on offer too.
MyStart Health has the edge with a 8.5 rating.
PeterMD focuses on compounded medications at a lower price point.
Compare their support: MyStart Health offers u.s.-licensed doctors you can reach without any cap on clinician visits, while PeterMD provides licensed doctors who handle screening over a virtual visit.
MyStart Health at $224/month may offer features that justify the premium.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is MyStart Health better than PeterMD?
MyStart Health has a 8.5 rating while PeterMD has a 5.5 rating. The better choice depends on your priorities — MyStart Health is best for people who value a money-back results pledge alongside a frozen price, while PeterMD is best for penny-pinchers hunting for the cheapest possible monthly glp-1 price.
How much does MyStart Health cost compared to PeterMD?
MyStart Health starts at $224/month (normally $299/mo; code selflove25 trims 25% off to $224/mo. meds, labs, shipping, and unlimited clinician access all included), while PeterMD starts at $105/month (subscription pairs semaglutide with b12; tirzepatide is on offer too).
Do MyStart Health and PeterMD accept insurance?
MyStart Health does not accept insurance. PeterMD does not accept insurance.
Which GLP-1 medications does MyStart Health offer vs PeterMD?
MyStart Health offers Compounded Semaglutide, Compounded Tirzepatide, Ozempic, Wegovy. PeterMD offers Compounded Semaglutide + B12, Compounded Tirzepatide.
Can I cancel MyStart Health or PeterMD at any time?
MyStart Health allows cancel anytime. PeterMD also allows cancel anytime.
Are MyStart Health and PeterMD available in my state?
MyStart Health is available in all 50 states. PeterMD is available in 46 states.
Not sure MyStart Health or PeterMD is right for you?
Take our 6-question quiz and we'll point you to the program that fits your budget and goals best.